Saturday, October 15, 2011

I Wanna...Put an End to the Idea that Americans are Slackers.


How many high school students do you know that look like this?


Honestly.
 Two Million Minutes. Great movie, but terrible, terrible hasty generalizations. I enjoyed it. It was inspiring. But at the same time a huge blow to the self-esteem of a wannabe engineer. The goal of this movie is respectable. Rah! for patriotism. We will always be the world’s greatest super power! Blah, Blah, Blah. But just like every documentary, I can’t help from thinking every aspect of that film was staged. The indifferent American genius, the Grey’s Anatomy Genetics study party, everything led to the director’s point. American’s are lazy, but fortunate in that we still can be very successful. It’s more competitive for Asians, but even making room to study twenty-five hours a day may not be enough to get what they want. This film was very successful in using scare tactics, to argue one underlying point. With increased globalization these past few decades, competition is transglobal, and America is falling behind. And I totally agree, after seeing the work ethic of some high school students from the viewpoint of one of their peers. Wayzata High School has 26 AP classes to offer. The cheapest way to get college credits. So why do students choose to slide by with a schedule of History of Film, Personal Family Issues 1, Personal Family Issues 2, and Marine Biology? (I don’t mean to bash these classes, I have just heard some things about the effort they require).

But I also see American high school students hard at work, involved in everything, truly seizing every opportunity presented to them. Whites, African-Americans and Asian-Americans all living in their studies. I don’t have a problem with socializing, and in so many career opportunities people-smarts is just as important as book-smarts. I refuse to believe we are going to loose influence in the future years just because we’re graduating fewer engineers.

From my understanding of I Wanna be Average, the reason many students aren't succeeding is because the bobber isn't being thrown out far enough off the shore. Rose uses this metaphor to describe a specific time of his life when vocational education students weren't succeeding because teachers weren't setting the bar high enough. A counterargument to this thought is presented by Patrick Welsh in his article For Once Blame the Students. Welsh stresses student self-initiative, and I think he really respects students that posses a desire to learn. But from my personal experience, I think both are flaws in the American education system. I think it’s ridiculous that some teachers don’t assign work just because they don’t want to grade it. I think it’s even more ridiculous that some students just choose not to do their homework some nights. To be honest, I don’t have a proposal, but the attention these literary works are bringing to these issues are the first steps to changing our system for the better.

6 comments:

  1. I love the Cartoon! It definitely sets the tone.

    I also agree with the fact that WHS offers 26 AP classes,therefore, we have a chance to get ahead. There are students that load up on bogus electives and don't want to try. But many of the people loading up on AP Classes actually want to get somewhere in life.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I honestly couldn't agree more about people taking those classes (even though I have a secret drive to take PFAM so that I can do a parenthesis). We have so many options to get ahead in classes, and not enough people take advantage of it. But it's kind of fun to be looked up to for taking hard courses, haha

    ReplyDelete
  3. I LOVE the cartoon. Hilarious. And yes ive seen some Senior Year schedules that make me roll my eyes, yet those students will still get into a decent college. It makes me grind my teeth to see how hard the people in China and India have to work and I can't help but feel like we set our standards too low, example, what you said about those classes haha.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Yes, I admit it. I have taken marine biology. And you're right. I think there might have been 3 nights when I was actually assigned homework. A reading was assigned every day, but it was easy to get by without doing it. Wait, did I just prove that Americans are lazy? shoot.

    I completely agree that Americans were shown in a negative light in the film. I was even embarrassed for our culture and the way we handle education. But then I think about all of the extracurriculars that my friends are in, how much we volunteer, and how involved we are in the community. Another thing is, we may not be as book smart according to standardized testing and things, but the social skills we gain from being part of a community are almost just as important.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Actually a huge self-esteem killer. Bridget- I agree completely. I don't know about all of you, but I would much rather have social skills than a perfect score on a standardized test! When it is all said and done I want to look back and think of how much fun I had and all the important relationships I have built. Speaking of relationships... isn't that how a lot of people get so far in life? I seem to remember hearing (on multiple occasions) that it is all about WHO you know. I guess we'll find out in ten years, right?

    ReplyDelete
  6. Andrew, you spotted the central argument of the film. You win! Nobody else (based on the posts I've read so far) has mentioned that.

    ReplyDelete